A bad day at MOWOG

The MG Experience ~ MGB & GT Forum ~ Archives

MG MGB and MGB GT Tech Talk

If you would like to post a reply, please click below to visit the The MG Experience Forums:
MGB & GT Forum: A bad day at MOWOG
http://www.mgexperience.net/phorum/read.php?1,756871,page=1

Join the discussion, post your photos, or ask your own questions. Membership is FREE!




Mar 23, 2008 17:15:44
JimmyHilton

Not that any manifolds had the precision that would be nice, but this one takes the cake. Manifolds, heat shields, spacers, and gaskets can be a challenge to assemble to make a decent path. On this particular manifold, the stud to port clearance is way off on both sides.

The pits is I had it all cleaned up and ready to go with replated studs fitted, and all custom fittings for Adam Stockwell's '68. Then I set the heat shield on it, and went Oh Sh__.

Pics of the worst side:

Mar 23, 2008 17:18:29
Gerry

Well, what you going to do about it? Grind the port or relocate the studs?





Mar 23, 2008 17:20:41
JimmyHilton

Gerry Wrote:

Quote: "
Well, what you going to do about it? Grind the port or relocate the studs?
"


Pulled everything and got another manifold ready. The carb fit would have been the same.

Gerry, the right way to fix it would be to move the studs. That is beyond my reasonable capabilities.

Anyone need a bad manifold for "Garage Wall Art"? If it were a misstamped 40 year old penny, it would be worth something.

Mar 23, 2008 17:36:27
bobmunch

Ouch! Makes a person appreciate that theirs came out OK, especially since Moss lists them as NA. There probably are some repros somewhere I suppose, but if there are, are they as good as OE? Better?

Mar 23, 2008 18:06:32
twigworker

Sorry for the trouble Jimmie, but this is a great example to the heathen that what is preached asp often about attention to detail is very important. Haste may seem appropriate sometimes but careful, methodical work pays off every time.

Jack

Mar 23, 2008 18:24:42
workinearly

OK. It is obviously an OE manifold. It came bolted to a B at one time which means it was made properly and got screwed up at a later date. What's your point other than you didn't notice it earlier?

Mar 23, 2008 18:32:14
JimmyHilton

David,

Out of the couple of hundred or so I have here, I just now found the bad apple.

Mar 23, 2008 18:54:21
omextreme

Wow do I win an award for having such an off manifold? Anyway I am sending you another manifold and HS4 set tomorrow to add to your collection. Thanks for the hard work. I cannot wait to see the pictures.

Mar 23, 2008 19:55:21
twentyover

workinearly Wrote:

Quote: "
OK. It is obviously an OE manifold. It came bolted to a B at one time which means it was made properly and got screwed up at a later date. What's your point other than you didn't notice it earlier?
"


Think you're making an assumption here. Why are you assuming it wasn't screwed up at the factory? You're suggesting that someone went to the troble to weld the existing holes closed (in an alloy of the same color as the base alloy, not as easy as on might think) and offset drill the holes 3/32" or so. This is much more likely a factory screw up.

The manifold has MOWOG cast into it- I don't see this a being a repop, as counterfeit parts are generally made of high volume parts, not ancient stuff we use

Mar 23, 2008 20:14:36
JimmyHilton

Adam,

As you knew, I was getting some of my parts ready for you as I already had a '68 set of AUD265's on the shelf and ready to go. It takes a several days of soaking in the vat to clean the internals of an intake, and this one had already been cleaned. I had cleaned up the mounting surfaces, installed freshly plated studs, and gotten all the fittings set up for your application. Then went to mount the heatshield and saw the above.

After that I finished cleaning up the manifold that you sent me, and it is just fine!

As I said before, the parts are never perfect but I've never seen one anywhere near this far off before. Actually it was close to 3/16" off.

Mar 24, 2008 06:55:44
PaulM


That is a good posting Jimmy...something to be aware of.

thanks

Mar 24, 2008 07:23:03
Bill Young

Jimmy, a question for the expert. Does the stud spacing change with the carb bore size? I was just wondering if that spacing would fit a larger size SU? Just wondering if this manifold might have been accidently machined for the larger carb, if so it would make a nice race piece once the ports were opened up.

Mar 24, 2008 13:03:57
JimmyHilton

Hi Bill,

On HS4 and HS6 carbs the spacing is the same, although there are only 2 diagonal holes in the HS4 and 4 square in the HS6.

Actually, the carbs slides freely onto the two misplaced studs. The studs were just positioned way off from where they should have been.

The car this manifold originally came from would have had a very badly interupted flow. I suppose more are possible.

Mar 24, 2008 13:29:46
danc

When I see things like that I think. Thats what happens after lunch at the Pub.

Mar 24, 2008 15:21:48
B-racer

I think you got it nailed Dan! Either that or on Monday morning, Friday afternon...

I have BOXES of distributor parts that fall in the same category! Rivets that were never pressed, 6 cylinder parts in 4 cyl distributors and vice-versa, crappy castings with pores clean through them, shafts that were partially machined off-center, etc...

Mar 25, 2008 06:48:03
twentyover

Jimmy-

Maybe these manifolds were custom prepared for the special ‘offset drilled’ SU’s made last Monday at the SU factory after a weekend of too much partying

Mar 25, 2008 06:58:37
underdog

I've seen people use the HS 4 manifold with HS6s and only useing the two studs and opening the manifold up to suit. Perhaps that could be done with this one rather than scrap it?

Mar 25, 2008 07:47:14
bills

In a perfect world, 'blueprinting' an engine would be unecessary as the factory would make them all to exact specified measure. This is just an object lesson in why blueprinting an engine can gain 4-5% power - you are fixing the minor (in his case a bit more than that) screw-ups allowed by factory tolerance or negligence.

Which is why we 'pin' specific manifolds to specific heads - and redo it if we need to change either in race cars.


Mar 25, 2008 16:16:15
JimmyHilton

twentyover Wrote:

Quote: "Jimmy-
Maybe these manifolds were custom prepared for the special ‘offset drilled’ SU’s made last Monday at the SU factory after a weekend of too much partying "

Greg, I think that is the best bet!!

Mar 25, 2008 16:29:51
moreso74

Jimmy - I'll take manifold. I've got an idea on what to use it for. If it doesn't work out, then no loss. PM me for shipping arrangements.

Mar 25, 2008 16:36:43
JimmyHilton

David,

You are more than welcome to it, for whatever it costs to get it to You.

Are you starting a museum?

Mar 25, 2008 17:09:08
underdog

I think the price of SU manifolds, that are centered, just doubled! Think I saw one on ebay up to $175.00 Sorry, Just kidn ;) The oddball one would probably be worth more.:)

Mar 25, 2008 17:12:08
bills

That one would be perfect for hogging out to fit 1 3/4" SUs......

Mar 25, 2008 17:20:49
JimmyHilton

bills Wrote:

Quote: "
That one would be perfect for hogging out to fit 1 3/4" SUs...... "


Bill,

It could sure be done, but there could also be some linkage misalignment because of the offset.

Mar 25, 2008 17:24:20
bills

JimmyHilton Wrote:

Quote: "
bills Wrote:Quote:
That one would be perfect for hogging out to fit 1 3/4" SUs......
Bill,
It could sure be done, but there could also be some linkage misalignment because of the offset.
"


Yup - not sure if they machined both holes with one set up - one jig. If so both sets would be off; if not, you're right, one set may be misaligned with the other set.

Mar 25, 2008 17:30:29
JimmyHilton

underdog Wrote:

Quote: "
I think the price of SU manifolds, that are centered, just doubled! Think I saw one on ebay up to $175.00 Sorry, Just kidn The oddball one would probably be worth more."


Jim, That'd be just great!! I could get rid of the couple hundred "good" manifolds I have here, and make way more than I could on building a couple hundred sets of carbs!! ;)

This is an archived discussion from the The MG Experience Forums

If you would like to post a reply, please click below to visit the The MG Experience Forums:
MGB & GT Forum: A bad day at MOWOG


Archive Index | The MG Experience Forums | Return to The MG Experience