California smog test - two entirely different vehicles

The MG Experience ~ Other Vehicles ~ Archives

For discussion of any cars that aren't MG. Classic or modern, import or domestic, cars trucks and motorcycles welcome.

If you would like to post a reply, please click below to visit the The MG Experience Forums:
Other Vehicles: California smog test - two entirely different vehicles
http://www.mgexperience.net/phorum/read.php?69,1981026,page=1

Join the discussion, post your photos, or ask your own questions. Membership is FREE!




Feb 09, 2012 19:04:29
circlip

Had to take the 2005 Chevrolet Silverado 2500HD truck for a smog test (enhanced test - Silly Valley area) today.

The tech let me watch the whole process, but he got very frustrated as his machine (Windows 95 based) completely locked up twice near the end of the test.

Eventually succeeded on the third try after turning the truck around to put it in the bay forwards, instead of bass ackwards (long story).

Once home, I compared the results to a recent test of my wife's 2001 Acura 3.2TL (ULEV engine). Somewhat surprising results I thought.

I can go into details, if anyone is interested.

Feb 09, 2012 20:22:10
Youngmgbuilder

Go on..........





Feb 09, 2012 21:38:16
circlip

Quote: "
Go on..........
"


Ok, here goes....

They do two "dyno pulls", one at 15mph and the other at 25mph.

The Acura is front wheel drive, automatic 5 speed trans, 3.2 litre V6.

The Chevy Silverado truck is rear wheel drive, manual 5 speed trans, 6.0 litre V8.

Acura:

%CO2 - 14.8 - both runs
%O2 - 0 - both runs - (i guess that's closed loop on the O2 sensors)

HC (PPM) - hydrocarbons
6 (above average) - 15mph
2 (below average) - 25mph

CO % - carbon monoxide
0 (below average) - 15 mph
0.01 (same as average) - 25 mph

NO (PPM) - Nitrous Oxide
10 - (Average is 16) - 15mph
10 - (Average is 18) - 25mph

So the Acura passed the test with flying colors.

Chevy Silverado:
%CO2:
6.85 - 15mph
6.79 - 25mph

%O2:
11.09 - 15mph
11.24 - 25mph

HC and CO:
All Zero - both runs

NO (PPM) - Nitrous Oxide
8 - 15mph
4 - 25mph

So the Chevy beats the ULEV Acura into the weeds on emissions testing at the local test station. But, then again, the test equipment was running on Windows 95, and the damn thing crapped out twice during the Chevy test. So who knows?

Not sure why the Chevy pushed out more O2, better lean burn setup perhaps? It also pushed a lot of H20 out of the tail pipe.

You may think that I have over analysed all this, but hey the tests cost $60.20 each, so why not get my money's worth :)

This is an archived discussion from the The MG Experience Forums

If you would like to post a reply, please click below to visit the The MG Experience Forums:
Other Vehicles: California smog test - two entirely different vehicles


Archive Index | The MG Experience Forums | Return to The MG Experience