Distributorless Ignition

The MG Experience ~ MGB & GT Forum ~ Archives

MG MGB and MGB GT Tech Talk

If you would like to post a reply, please click below to visit the The MG Experience Forums:
MGB & GT Forum: Distributorless Ignition
http://www.mgexperience.net/phorum/read.php?1,645219,page=1

Join the discussion, post your photos, or ask your own questions. Membership is FREE!




Oct 02, 2007 14:45:22
Basil Adams

A couple of pages back, some guys were discussing the difficulty in getting to their distributors after installing a crossflow head. I told them about the distributorless system I use on the racecar and promised to get info from the maker (Electromotive) on price and availability. Go to their website (www.electromotive-inc.com) and look at the XDI unit. I've re-established contact at the factory and they'll sell to me if we put together 3 units. If you're interested, PM me and I'll save you some money over the regular price. Thanks. Basil

Oct 02, 2007 15:24:55
sshack

Looks like they're having some technical difficulties.





Oct 02, 2007 15:55:44
B-racer

I've played with a similar, yet far less expensive system. Not enough time to really beta test it in the B, but it looks promising as well. I still prefer a good old-fashioned distributor! :-)

Oct 02, 2007 16:34:12
Basil Adams

sshack Wrote:

Quote: "
Looks like they're having some technical difficulties.
"


Steve, Try again. I just got right in. Basil

Oct 02, 2007 16:45:37
sshack

Looks like a more expensive version of megasquirt'n'spark.
Only less flexible.

with vems and megasquirt around I'm amazed that any company can still survive
selling such dated electronics.

Oct 02, 2007 19:27:50
mac townsend

Basil Adams Wrote:

Quote: "
A couple of pages back, some guys were discussing the difficulty in getting to their distributors after installing a crossflow head. I told them about the distributorless system I use on the racecar and promised to get info from the maker (Electromotive) on price and availability. Go to their website (www.electromotive-inc.com) and look at the XDI unit. I've re-established contact at the factory and they'll sell to me if we put together 3 units. If you're interested, PM me and I'll save you some money over the regular price. Thanks. Basil
"


What does this translate to in USD? Electramotive stuff has always been real pricey.

Oct 02, 2007 20:07:35
Basil Adams

It's not cheap, Mac. But not horrible either. Send me a PM and we'll discuss options. Basil

Oct 02, 2007 20:18:59
Basil Adams

sshack Wrote:

Quote: "
Looks like a more expensive version of megasquirt'n'spark.
Only less flexible.
with vems and megasquirt around I'm amazed that any company can still survive
selling such dated electronics.
"


Megasquirt is a fuel injection controller - I guess if you converted your MGB to FI it might work. VEMS is an aftermarket ECU package for cars equipped with electronic sensors. Again, if you went to FI and a throttle position switch, O2 sensor, MAF sensor... it might work. The Electromotive XDI technology is geared at cars like ours. Electromotive makes sophisticated units for fuel injected and ECU controlled engine management but that's not the discussion. This is just a simple post letting those people that were experiencing access issues with their crossflow heads that I've investigated an alternative we discussed on another thread and that I'm happy to pass on what I've found out. Thanks.

Oct 02, 2007 21:43:52
ingoldsb

Very interesting - thanks for doing the research Basil!

Oct 02, 2007 21:57:49
sshack

Point taken.

Though vems and megasquirt'n'spark can do just spark if desired.
Last time I looked both setups cost about a quarter of even the cheapest
of aftermarket ecu's and were much more powerful than even the highest end stuff.

They also don't razzle dazzle you with marketspeak technobabble bullshit.

Oct 03, 2007 00:32:15
Basil Adams

But would either of them work on an MGB??? Prolly not. And the last I looked at a mega squirt, it was a kit you had to solder together. The price for the basic VEMS module is about $650 and that's all you get.

Oct 03, 2007 03:16:46
Speedracer

Electromotive is a fine stand alone crank fire ignition, as Basil mentioned, SCCA guys have used them for awhile, I have atleast 17 years experience with these units myself. For the longest time the system came as one piece box, and you ordered them based on your cylinder count (1 coils per two cylinder) the 4 cylinder unit had two coils for example, same coils as used on the systems you've seen in the GM cars for years, in fact this company also maded those ignitions for GM. The only catch for this set up was different boxes need to be made for different cylinder counts, so about 4 years ago, the company decided to go to a split unit one universal main box that could be manually switched from anything from one cylinder to 16 cylinders, and then a separate coil box depending on how many cylinders you have, at this time, these systems almost doubled in price. over my many years of using them, I would have to say I've been overall pleased in thier reliablity, I had one pick up go out, it was probably ten year old when it went, fried one unit like a knucklehead by welding on the car with the ignition in the chassis, later found out, if you are going to weld on your car, you are suppose to remove the system, other than that they gave me many years of performance and reliabilty. The neatest thing about the Electromotive is you have manual dials to set your advance at a given rpm, no need for a laptop hook up, they also have rev limiters built in as well. You have a little bit of custom work to deal with on these units, for example you have to make something to hold the trigger lead, we mostly made these form aluminum and thet bolted on the front engine plate, then you have to bore a center hole in the trigger wheel and mount it to your harmonice balancer, so you need to be able to little custom machining work or know someone who can do this for you.

Oct 03, 2007 03:23:18
Speedracer

Here's a picture of a trigger mount and the trigger wheel mount I made up for a guy's 948 dry sump engine he ran in his SCCA Bugeye race car.

Oct 03, 2007 05:03:10
B-racer

The Megajolt Lite Jr. can be ordered fully assembled - just wire it in with a crank sensor and a MAP vacuum line and adjust the program if needed. All for under $300. I've devised a very inexpensive crank trigger wheel, and a new sensor can be had for under $30. Add a restriced vacuum line from the manifold and you're about finished!

Oct 03, 2007 08:29:48
twentyover

Think Megajoule lite also comes as an alpha-N option for those running low vacuum cams.

I guess I'm questioning the importance of the manual adjustment on Electromotive- After initial setup on a dyno, or a series of acceleration runs, how often do you change timing at the track? Crank triggers shouldn't drift like distributors.

On initial setup in a dyno cell, one more laptop won't make much difference.....

Oct 03, 2007 10:05:35
B-racer

I didn't mention that you can use a TPS rather than a MAP sensor with the Megajolt as well - they come configured either way, so if you have a low vacuum cam, its not really an issue. Just a bit more programming to be done.

Oct 03, 2007 11:58:11
Speedracer

twentyover Wrote:

Quote: "
Think Megajoule lite also comes as an alpha-N option for those running low vacuum cams.
I guess I'm questioning the importance of the manual adjustment on Electromotive- After initial setup on a dyno, or a series of acceleration runs, how often do you change timing at the track? Crank triggers shouldn't drift like distributors.
On initial setup in a dyno cell, one more laptop won't make much difference.....
"


True, after you dial it in you won't mess with it much, but it takes only seconds to make a change, and unlike the Mega Squirt, there's nothing to fiquire out, it's a very simple system. The first thing you will notice when compared to a distributor is how rock solid it is when timing it. Another thing to keep in mind, what makes the absolute most horsepower on the dyno will probably not be what you end up using for the street or track, as it will be too edgy to reliable for the long haul. I tne d to take guys and start them ot very conservatively, then let them advance the timing very so slightly, go out and try iy, if the car behaves, then try some more timing, generaly if you try to run too much timing at the track it will show up first in increase water temps, then you know you've went to far. On the dyno lets says I make the best horsepower at 35 degrees advanced, I wouldn't dare think of sending the car out on track for longer runs with that, I may start at say 32 degree advanced for example then work my way up in advance if all goes well, this is also where EGT or AFR gauge start to pay off. One way to look at the Electromotive vs say the Mega Squirt, if the electromotive will allow you a quicker learning curve and thereforth keep you track for more seat time, vs a system that may take serval dyno run and track testing to get a grasp on, then the Electromotive may end up being the cheaper system, it's all about what you want to do and how much learning curve you're willing to give, with Electromotive, becuase so many people have used them on this type of application, there is hardly any learning curve.

Oct 03, 2007 13:11:18
bills

Is a crank fired ignition legal in vintage racing where you run, Basil? It isn't around here or I'd have gone to it long ago.

Oct 03, 2007 13:25:23
Basil Adams

Bill, I don't vintage race and I don't know of a vintage organization that specifically allows it. A couple of guys with crossflow heads were just talking about what a pain it is to get to their distributors on the right side under the carbs. However, if you wanted to do it, you don't need a crank trigger. There's a pick-uip wheel that you can mount right where the base plate of your distributor was and you get to use the more reliable systemand it still looks like a distributor - just no points, condensor... Basil

This is an archived discussion from the The MG Experience Forums

If you would like to post a reply, please click below to visit the The MG Experience Forums:
MGB & GT Forum: Distributorless Ignition


Archive Index | The MG Experience Forums | Return to The MG Experience