Speaking Of HDTV's

The MG Experience ~ Off Topic Forum ~ Archives

General non-MG related discussions. No politics here please!!

If you would like to post a reply, please click below to visit the The MG Experience Forums:
Off Topic Forum: Speaking Of HDTV's
http://www.mgexperience.net/phorum/read.php?47,1293088,page=1

Join the discussion, post your photos, or ask your own questions. Membership is FREE!




Nov 29, 2009 06:11:45
Naomi

We have two HDTV's. One is a Sony and the other a Panasonic. The Sony is 720P and the Panasonic is 1080P and I can't see a darn bit of difference in picture quality, sound quality of even craftsmanship when watching HDTV, DVDs, etc.
Ya'll are smart about these things. In simple terms, that I can understand, why exactly did we pay more for the 1080? It was the sales folks that talked us into it but what is suppose to be so great about the 1080 ?


Your turn :)

Nov 29, 2009 06:56:18
TRB

unless the tv is big(50+ inches) or you sit really close, there isn't much difference

http://reviews.cnet.com/720p-vs-1080p-hdtv/





Nov 29, 2009 07:11:38
S. Duerr

Take a picture and enlarge it on your screen. You'll notice that, as it gets larger you can see the pixles. The more pixles you have, the larger you can get the picutre before you loose picture quality. So, a 1080 has a lot more dots/sq inch than a 720 and the screen can get larger before you start to see the dots. :)

Nov 29, 2009 07:20:04
Dwain

Do you have a 1080P signal source?

Nov 29, 2009 07:31:58
Naomi

Quote: "
Do you have a 1080P signal source?"


Yep -- the Blu-Ray DVD Player and we do rent the Blu-Ray movies. Maybe because the sets we have only 40" screens -- would that make a difference??

Nov 29, 2009 08:03:41
dcdci

Boy, it almost makes me yearn for the days of my youth when we had just 7 channels. ABC, NBC, CBS and 3 independents plus the "educational" channel 13. And they offered everything we could want. National news and our favorite shows on the big networks. All our local sports teams on the independents. Documentaries, classical music and educational kids shows on 13. Best of all it didn't cost a dime. And if you wanted to see a movie or just cool off in the heat of the summer you went to the movies for a buck and a quarter. Oh, for the good old days.







They're coming next week to switch our Standard Definition DIRECTV over to 200+ channels of glorious 1080pHD.

Nov 29, 2009 08:33:15
Rod H.

Todd nailed it. See the chart below, which explains it all. With a 42" screen, unless you sit about 5.5' or 6' away you might as well get 720p.

http://www.carltonbale.com/wp-content/uploads/distance_chart.png

Nov 29, 2009 08:36:15
losmorob

Or how about an antenna on your roof with an electric motor "rotator" attached. You would have a box for the rotator on top of your TV. As it turned, the box would click-click away.

Looking at 720 vs 1080 I don't see much of a difference. Unless you're playing Playstation 3 games. :eyepop:

Nov 29, 2009 08:51:44
Naomi

Quote: "
Or how about an antenna on your roof with an electric motor "rotator" attached. You would have a box for the rotator on top of your TV. As it turned, the box would click-click away.
:"


Wow you had an electric motor to do that? Mom and Dad made us kids go out and hand turn the thing to bring in different stations and sometimes ( like the news ) they would make us stand there and hold it dead still in place -- honest :)

PS: I have to agree though that I liked those simpler times much better :)

Nov 29, 2009 08:59:07
losmorob

We had all the bells and whistles as my dad was a Ham radio operator and he built all his stuff. He built a Heathkit color TV in the early 60's. We were the first on the block. I was just a toddler then, but I remember many times my dad behind the tv adjusting and saying, "better, or worse."]

Nov 29, 2009 09:25:52
Naomi

Quote: "
We had all the bells and whistles as my dad was a Ham radio operator and he built all his stuff. He built a Heathkit color TV in the early 60's. We were the first on the block. I was just a toddler then, but I remember many times my dad behind the tv adjusting and saying, "better, or worse."]"


I remember those men! One of my friend's Dad was a Ham radio operator and he had postcards from other operators. Called em "Wall Paper" and they were hanging all over the wall in the room where the radio was at. He put the antenna across the river and on top of the mountain and ran those wire all the way there. It was fun riding with their family in the Willy's Jeep to check the antenna. Wow you brought up a nice memory from the past for me :) :)

Nov 29, 2009 11:32:33
Elfis Presley

My first HDTV was a Mitsubishi 55 inch rear projection, I never did get used to it. No matter how far you sat from it, it still was too big so I gave it to my elderly neighbor for free. I bought a Vizio, 32 inch HD Flatscreen Plasma, never seen a better picture but I wanted a bigger screen so I gave that one to my sister. Recently I upgraded to a Vizio 47 HD LCD, I'm loving this tv especially with Directv HD package.

Nov 29, 2009 15:33:09
Wasper

Well, I have an Olevia 55" 1080p HDTV and it helps a lot with the higher pixels when watching HD programing or Blueray movies. I bought this brand because I had some free "swag money" for helping out with the tech forums at a popular PC and electronic online store (Newegg). So they gave me a huge deal on it and I've been very happy.

My sister has a LG 37" 720p HDTV and it looks just fine. So I agree it has to do with size and viewing distance.

Elvis, my father-in-law bought a Vizio 47" HDTV and I agree, it is very good quality, especially since your paying much less then some of the Japanese companies.

My wife just picked up some cheapo brand (Apex) 40" 1080p HDTV on Black Friday for about $380...it wouldn't be my first choice, but if my wife comes in the door with a 40" 1080p HDTV, I tend not to ask to many question, lol. Ive yet to hook it up as I'm awaiting my wall mount. As long as it works I'll be happy... after all, it is just going in the bedroom.

Nov 29, 2009 20:26:20
Wray

Quote: "

Wow you had an electric motor to do that? Mom and Dad made us kids go out and hand turn the thing to bring in different stations and sometimes ( like the news ) they would make us stand there and hold it dead still in place -- honest :)

PS: I have to agree though that I liked those simpler times much better :)"


Na, we hams called that an "Armstrong" rotator.

Nov 29, 2009 20:45:44
MudSnow

If you use it as a computer monitor, you can definitely see the difference.

Nov 29, 2009 20:47:46
S. Duerr

Quote: "
Or how about an antenna on your roof with an electric motor "rotator" attached. You would have a box for the rotator on top of your TV. As it turned, the box would click-click away."


We had one, too. The motor broke so my dad handed me a pipe wrench and said to go twist until he yelled stop. That was the method until we got cable.

This is an archived discussion from the The MG Experience Forums

If you would like to post a reply, please click below to visit the The MG Experience Forums:
Off Topic Forum: Speaking Of HDTV's


Archive Index | The MG Experience Forums | Return to The MG Experience