What gauges are we lookin at anyway??? :S

The MG Experience ~ MGB & GT Forum ~ Archives

MG MGB and MGB GT Tech Talk

If you would like to post a reply, please click below to visit the The MG Experience Forums:
MGB & GT Forum: What gauges are we lookin at anyway??? :S
http://www.mgexperience.net/phorum/read.php?1,1980390,page=1

Join the discussion, post your photos, or ask your own questions. Membership is FREE!




Feb 09, 2012 08:45:08
balloonfoot

I just got an email from a fellow who installed a late O/D box in a 67 MGB and converted to negative ground. He now has the on going speedo/tach problem...what to do. Comes up every month or so like clockwork.

I DO NOT believe in getting a speedo 'recalibrated' by some guy who fixes old Hudson gauges. I do it the way the factory would have.

Example: If I am using a 68-73 1280TPM trans....I get a 68-73 1280TPM speedo from England. They used the same 100mm gauge with matching face as the 63-67 cars. Super easy to get.

If you are using a 1000TPM trans, it gets a bit more specific. No MGB used a 100mm early face style 1000tpm gauge. However, other cars did. The BJ8 Healey had a 1000TPM 140mph gauge (64-67). That is the gauge that is in my 67 roadster (see picture). It is not an exact match.....the center of the needle is different. For an exact match you need a 75-76 UK Midget speedo (see picture). Why modify, why not just buy the correct one?

Same goes for the neg ground issue. Early MkII MGBs used the same RVI type tach as the positive ground 65-67 cars....but with neg ground. No need to change any wiring. The later large gauge UK MGB cars used the RVC type tach and is easy to wire...add 1 wire. The UK Spridget used the same setup but with a 6250 redline rather than 6000 like an MGB...see picture.

Feb 09, 2012 09:19:50
JoeReed

I suspect the reason most people don't do as you suggest is that they simply were not aware of those options. Great advice (as usual)!





Feb 09, 2012 09:28:21
oily-hands

That'll get the odometer right. The correct way is to change the gearing in the speedo drive in the gearbox.

I doubt if the factory ever considered fitting a late model OD to an early car.

You're right, it does come up often and the same incorrect answers are given.

Feb 09, 2012 09:28:32
rlich8

Lloyd, what about an early car?

If I recall properly, I heard the non-OD 3-synchro boxes are 1040tpm, and the OD 3-synchro boxes are 1000 (or 1020 maybe?).

I have a '63, which has a 1040 Jaeger.

So, with such a small discrepancy...is it worth it to even modify mine?

Feb 09, 2012 09:35:55
balloonfoot

Quote: "
Lloyd, what about an early car?

If I recall properly, I heard the non-OD 3-synchro boxes are 1040tpm, and the OD 3-synchro boxes are 1000 (or 1020 maybe?).

I have a '63, which has a 1040 Jaeger.

So, with such a small discrepancy...is it worth it to even modify mine?
"


"The correct way is to change the gearing in the speedo drive in the gearbox"....Owen, sorry to disagree, but the early cars (63-67) had 1020 or 1040 speedo gears and matching speedos....there are no such gears for the 4 synchro box. Therefore you must match the speedo to the gears in the trans....like I said.

Rich.....you are correct about the 1020/1040 speedos....no 1000 speedos. "Close enough" is always too expensive for me...I always go for right on and avoid the hassles. (:D

Feb 09, 2012 09:52:33
balloonfoot

Everybody....please with the emails, OK?

I just offered this up as the easy/correct way to fix your late trans/early car problem. I don't care how you choose to do it. Really...don't have no horse in this race.

The older I get, the more annoying I find certain tasks on an MGB. Removing/replacing the gauges is one of them. I hate that job....so I don't want to do it. I say do it right and forget it.

Someday, when I restore my 67 (IF I RESTORE IT) I'll make everything pretty. For now, I just want to know how fast the engine is going and how fast the car is going.

My 2 cents.

Feb 09, 2012 10:54:21
oily-hands

Quote: "


"The correct way is to change the gearing in the speedo drive in the gearbox"....Owen, sorry to disagree, but the early cars (63-67) had 1020 or 1040 speedo gears and matching speedos....there are no such gears for the 4 synchro box. Therefore you must match the speedo to the gears in the trans....like I said.


"



There are no gears in the speedo part of the head, only in the odometer. If the correct gears for the drive aren't availabble then ther is a problem but I have to ask how changing one head for another is going to correct that problem.

The only way this would work is if the speedo parts, magnet & hairspring, are different in each model of speedo. To the best of my knowledge there are no differences, but my knowledge may not be complete.

I'm happy to be shown the error of my ways.

Feb 09, 2012 11:11:36
balloonfoot

The speedo is calibrated via the hairspring and magnet etc. The odo is calibrated by the gears in the head as you state. They all work based on the tpm on the face of the gauge. What you are saying is this: If your MGB uses a 1280TPM gauge and you swapped in a 1000TPM gauge, the speed would not be effected...only the odo would be wrong. That is simply not true...as dozens of people on this forum have discovered. Whatever.....as I stated, I have no horse in this race.

Feb 09, 2012 11:17:40
AzMarc

I think most of us enjoy the polite banter...... (tu)

Feb 09, 2012 11:43:19
ozieagle

Quote: "
Same goes for the neg ground issue. Early MkII MGBs used the same RVI type tach as the positive ground 65-67 cars....but with neg ground. No need to change any wiring. The later large gauge UK MGB cars used the RVC type tach and is easy to wire...add 1 wire.
"


Sorry Lloyd, but I must disagree.

The early RVI tachos (RVI 2401/008) were constructed for positive earth. To use one in a negative earth situation would toast the transistors. To correctly use it the power wires to the internal circuit board must be reversed.
The later version (RVI 2439/00) is inherently negative earth, and has totally different internals.

Herb

Feb 09, 2012 11:53:24
balloonfoot

Herb...you missed my point....which is the early posi ground cars used the RVI type tach and a 100mm gauge face. 68-71 UK MGBs used the same RVI type 100mm tach but with negative ground. Therefore....the easy switch is to use the UK tach when you switch your early car to negative ground....just stick it in, no wiring changes or "internal fixes" needed.

EDIT: I say the same "type" ie: RVI....I don't mean the exact same specific tach. Get a tach from a negative ground car and you are good to go. If the tach is an RVI type...then you won't need to modify the car's wiring.

Feb 09, 2012 12:58:08
RAY 67 TOURER

Wow. When I installed a 4 synchro/Od trans from a '72 into my '67, I used the internals from the '72 speedo inside the housing of my '67. An easy job, if you have a matching TPM speedo. RAY

Feb 09, 2012 14:15:10
ozieagle

Hi Lloyd,

It's not quite as simple as you say.
The +ve tach used a loop of the ign wire, through a gizmo (current transformer) external to the case, whilst the -ve ones had in internal gizmo, that had two connectors at the back. To fit one of these you would need to cut the ign wire, fit bullet connectors, the right way or it won't work, then connect to the tach sensing terminals.

Herb

Feb 09, 2012 14:36:12
balloonfoot

Herb...you are correct...early has external loop....negative ground version has internal loop with wires sticking out the back.....snip the loop, check which way is the correct way (by trial and error...only 2 options) and fit up. No need to string an extra sensing wire to coil as you would with a RVC tach....no taking of anything apart...well within the capabilities of the MGB owner.

Feb 10, 2012 06:38:30
mgbtf

I learn something new on this site nearly every day. Thanks Lloyd and everyone else.

Feb 10, 2012 07:38:47
AzMarc

...and that's what it's all about!


Quote: "
I learn something new on this site nearly every day. Thanks Lloyd and everyone else.
"

This is an archived discussion from the The MG Experience Forums

If you would like to post a reply, please click below to visit the The MG Experience Forums:
MGB & GT Forum: What gauges are we lookin at anyway??? :S


Archive Index | The MG Experience Forums | Return to The MG Experience