Its probably a 1974. Production usually began in Sept. or October of the year prior to the model year, at least during those years. In the early years, the model year concept was not very well-defined.
You can find out more, by getting a Heritage Certificate. Officially known as a Production Record Trace Certificate, it will tell you the exact date(s) that the car went through the Abingdon plant, original color, engine number, transmission number, key numbers and factory installed equipment. It comes on a a nice, ready-to-frame certificate. Its a bit pricey. I think that, at the current exchange rate, it is about $50. Go to http://www.heritage.org.uk/archive/trace.htm
Titles are often wrong with these cars. If the car was, at some point in the past, found in a barn and rebuilt, it may have been assigned a new title. Often the inspectors see the build date and use that for the model year.
If you have a printed Moss catalog, they have a chart in the front that relates VIN to model year. I haven't been able to find it on their website.